
Blackheads and whiteheads: why squeezing makes them worse, and what actually clears them
They are blocked pores, not dirt. What is inside the plug, what to try at home, what to skip, and when a clinic or a doctor adds something.
- Written by
- Clinic Eximus clinical team
- Updated
- Reading time
- 12 minutes
The short answer
Blackheads and whiteheads are the same thing in two forms: a pore plugged with oil and dead skin cells. The black is not dirt, which is why scrubbing, squeezing and pore strips rarely help and often leave irritated skin or a dark mark that outlasts the blackhead itself. A small number of well-studied ingredients, used gently for several weeks, do more than anything in the kitchen cupboard. This guide explains what is happening in the pore and what to try today. If you are weighing a clinic facial or a peel, the Hydrafacial and chemical peel pages cover how those work and what they cost. This page is the explanation behind them.
In this article
- Blackheads and whiteheads are the same blocked pore, open or closed
- Why squeezing and pore strips make blackheads worse, not better
- What clears blackheads: four ingredient families with evidence
- Main options for blackheads and whiteheads compared
- Toothpaste, baking soda, lemon and egg-white masks: what to skip
- Blackhead removal by a professional: what a clinician can do that you cannot do safely
- Chemical peels and prescription creams: when a doctor adds something
- When whiteheads and blackheads mean acne that needs a doctor
- A realistic 12-week plan, and what the options look like side by side
- What a gentle 12-week plan usually looks like
- The takeaway
- Questions before you book
- Sources
Blackheads and whiteheads are the same blocked pore, open or closed
Every pore is the opening of a hair follicle, with an oil gland (sebaceous gland) attached to it. When dead skin cells and oil pack into the follicle, the result is a comedo. DermNet NZ defines a comedo as a plugged follicular opening. If the opening stays wide, the plug is exposed to air and is called an open comedo, or blackhead. If the skin surface closes over the plug, it is a closed comedo, or whitehead.
The black is not dirt. The plug is made of oil and keratin, the protein that skin cells are built from, and it darkens where it meets air. This is commonly explained as oxidation of the oil, with pigment in the plug adding to the colour. DermNet describes open comedones as grey, orange, brown or black. Nothing on the surface is dirty, so washing harder does not lighten them. Whiteheads look skin-coloured or whitish because the plug sits beneath a thin roof of skin.
Both are the earliest stage of acne, and acne made mostly of these spots is called comedonal acne. They gather on the nose, chin and forehead, where oil glands are largest. Hormone changes, some cosmetic products and heavy oils can add to them. Many people have a few blackheads and nothing more. For others they are where inflamed spots begin, which is covered in the last sections below.
- Blackhead (open comedo): Flat or slightly raised dark dot. The plug is open to the air. Its contents can be extracted.
- Whitehead (closed comedo): Small skin-coloured or pale bump with no redness. It is sealed under skin and needs to be opened to release the contents.
Why squeezing and pore strips make blackheads worse, not better
Squeezing feels productive, but the American Academy of Dermatology warns that when you pop a spot at home you often push some of the contents deeper into the skin, which raises inflammation and can make acne more noticeable. Some people develop acne scars and pain, and bacteria from your hands can cause infection. The same page notes that squeezing out a blackhead can delay clearing.
In Indian skin there is a further cost. Inflamed or injured skin tends to heal with a brown mark, called post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation, and that mark can stay long after the blackhead is gone. A whitehead is harder still to treat at home, because DermNet notes that closed comedones have to be punctured before the contents can be removed, which is exactly the step that should be done with sterile tools by a trained person.
Pore strips lift the visible top off some plugs, which looks satisfying. But a strip does not change how much oil the gland makes or how quickly cells shed, so the plug usually refills. The adhesive can also irritate skin, and irritated skin in Fitzpatrick III to V skin tones is more likely to darken. We have not found trials showing that strips treat the cause, so we do not suggest them as a treatment.
Scrubs and harsh washes fail for a similar reason. The AAD advises against scrubbing, because it irritates skin and can make it look worse, and notes that a face wash that is too harsh can trigger more oil. Blackheads sit inside the follicle, below where a scrub reaches.
What clears blackheads: four ingredient families with evidence
The 2024 American Academy of Dermatology guideline for acne is the main reference here. It strongly recommends benzoyl peroxide and topical retinoids, and gives conditional recommendations (meaning the evidence is less certain) for salicylic acid and azelaic acid. These are described below as families, not products or doses. Which one suits you, and at what strength, is a decision for you and your doctor or pharmacist.
Salicylic acid dissolves in oil, so it can work inside the pore and loosen the plug. Topical retinoids, which are vitamin A derivatives, change how skin cells shed so plugs form less often. They are the most useful family for comedones, and also the one that dries and peels skin at first and makes it more sensitive to sun. Benzoyl peroxide kills acne bacteria and helps inflamed spots more than pure blackheads, but it can irritate and bleach fabric. Azelaic acid is gentle and also helps fade the dark marks that spots leave behind, which matters in brown skin.
How you start matters as much as what you start. Add one new product at a time, use it a few nights a week at first, and pair it with a plain moisturiser and a daily sunscreen. Irritation is the main reason people stop. Expect several weeks before blackheads look different, and judge a routine at around 12 weeks, which is how doctors review acne treatment. If you are pregnant, breastfeeding or planning a pregnancy, ask a doctor before using any of these, because some are not suitable at those times.
Main options for blackheads and whiteheads compared
| Compare | How it helps | What to know |
|---|---|---|
| Salicylic acid | How it helpsDissolves in oil, so it can loosen the plug inside the pore. | What to knowConditionally recommended in the AAD acne guideline. Can dry and sting, so start slowly. |
| Topical retinoid | How it helpsChanges how cells shed, so plugs form less often. | What to knowStrongly recommended for acne. Causes dryness and peeling at first and makes skin sun-sensitive. Ask a doctor if pregnant. |
| Benzoyl peroxide | How it helpsReduces acne bacteria and inflamed spots. | What to knowStrongly recommended for acne, but less aimed at pure blackheads. Can irritate and bleach fabric. |
| Azelaic acid | How it helpsGentle, and helps fade dark marks left by spots. | What to knowConditionally recommended. Slow to show an effect, so it needs weeks of use. |
| Professional extraction or facial | How it helpsClears the plugs that are there today with sterile technique. | What to knowResults are temporary without a routine. Not done on inflamed spots. |
| Superficial chemical peel | How it helpsLoosens the surface layer and unblocks pores. | What to knowSmaller evidence than prescription creams. Dark marks are a risk in Indian skin, so a doctor chooses the type. |
General information drawn from the sources below. Your doctor decides what suits you.
Toothpaste, baking soda, lemon and egg-white masks: what to skip
Home remedies for blackheads are some of the most shared tips online, and most of them either do nothing or irritate. Here is a plain sorting of the common ones. None of them removes the plug from inside the follicle, and several can leave a mark in skin that is prone to darkening.
- Skip: toothpaste: It is made for teeth, not skin. The ingredients can sting, dry and burn the skin, and it does not dissolve the plug.
- Skip: baking soda scrubs: Gritty and alkaline, so it can irritate and strip the skin barrier, and irritated skin can darken.
- Skip: lemon juice: Acidic, and combined with sunlight it can cause burns and brown marks on the skin. Do not use it on the face.
- Skip: egg-white peel-off masks and sugar or salt scrubs: No good evidence they clear blackheads. They pull on skin or scratch it, and egg can cause an allergic reaction.
- Harmless but low value: warm water, a plain clay mask now and then, an oil-free moisturiser: Not harmful for most people. They may reduce shine for a few hours, but they do not stop plugs from forming.
Blackhead removal by a professional: what a clinician can do that you cannot do safely
DermNet notes that the contents of an open comedo can be expressed or extracted, while a closed one has to be punctured. In a clinic, that is done on prepared skin with sterile tools by someone trained to judge how much pressure the skin can take and when to stop. Gentle extraction is also kept away from inflamed spots, because pressing on those pushes inflammation deeper.
A facial that combines cleansing, exfoliation and extraction in one visit is a common way to clear a congested nose and chin. Hydrafacial is the clinic's facial of this kind, and its page explains the steps, who it suits and what it costs. What to expect is the honest part: a facial clears the plugs that are there today, and without a routine that changes how the pore plugs up, blackheads usually return. Skin that has been extracted often looks pink for a short time. Anyone with active acne, rosacea or recent isotretinoin use should tell the clinician first, because that can change what is suitable.
Reading about it helps. A doctor looking at your skin is what tells you which of this applies to you.
Chemical peels and prescription creams: when a doctor adds something
If a routine of over-the-counter ingredients has not helped after about 12 weeks, or irritation keeps stopping it, a doctor can prescribe a stronger or better-tolerated retinoid or azelaic acid, or combine two with different actions. That is the same approach the AAD guideline describes for acne, where combining treatments that work in different ways is a good practice statement.
Superficial chemical peels use a controlled acid to loosen the surface layer of skin and unblock pores, and are one of the clinic options doctors may weigh for blackheads and comedonal acne. The evidence for peels is smaller than for prescription creams, so a peel is usually an addition, not a replacement. In Indian skin the type and strength of acid matter a great deal, because too strong a peel can leave dark marks. That is why the doctor decides, why a sunscreen routine starts before the peel and not after, and why a peel is not done on skin that is already irritated or inflamed.
When whiteheads and blackheads mean acne that needs a doctor
A few blackheads on the nose are common and rarely need more than a gentle routine. See a doctor sooner if any of these apply, because the earlier acne is treated, the lower the chance of scars and marks.
Whiteheads and blackheads spreading from the nose across the cheeks, forehead, chest or back are a sign of ongoing acne. Red, painful or pus-filled spots, or deep lumps, are inflamed acne and should not be squeezed. Dark marks or dips are appearing where spots were. Nothing has changed after about 12 weeks of careful use. The spots started suddenly in adult life, especially with irregular periods, new facial hair or thinning scalp hair, which a doctor will want to check for a hormonal cause such as PCOS. Acne is also affecting your mood or confidence, which the NHS notes is a recognised effect of the condition and a good reason to ask for help.
Our acne treatment page explains how a doctor assesses the type and severity, and the options they weigh. The existing acne treatment options post sets out the medicines and what to expect from them.
A realistic 12-week plan, and what the options look like side by side
Most blackhead plans fail because people stop early or add too much at once. The table above sets the main options side by side, and the timeline below shows what a patient, gentle plan usually looks like: one active at a time, sunscreen every morning, and a review at around 12 weeks. For the wider picture of pimple treatment, read our guide to acne treatment options.
What a gentle 12-week plan usually looks like
Phase 01 · Weeks 1 to 2
Start gently
Add one active, a few nights a week. Use a mild cleanser, a plain moisturiser and sunscreen every morning. Some dryness is expected.
Phase 02 · Weeks 3 to 8
Stay consistent
Move to nightly use only if skin is comfortable. Do not squeeze and do not add a second active at the same time. Change is gradual.
Phase 03 · Around week 12
Review
Compare photos taken in the same light. If little has changed, or irritation keeps interrupting, a doctor can adjust the plan.
The takeaway
Blackheads are plugged pores, not dirt. Leave them alone, introduce one proven ingredient gently, protect skin from the sun, and see a doctor if spots spread, hurt or leave marks.
Sources
- DermNet NZ: Comedo (blackheads and whiteheads) (opens in a new tab)
- Reynolds et al., Guidelines of care for the management of acne vulgaris, J Am Acad Dermatol 2024 (opens in a new tab)
- American Academy of Dermatology: Pimple popping (opens in a new tab)
- American Academy of Dermatology: Oily skin tips (opens in a new tab)
- NHS: Acne, types of spot and treatment (opens in a new tab)
- DermNet NZ: Acne vulgaris (opens in a new tab)





